Are Hybrid Vehicles Really Greener?
Tuesday, September 1st, 2009As the evidence of global warming becomes more obvious, governments, companies, and consumers all over the world are looking for ways to “go green.” Products and technologies that produce less carbon emissions are popular ways to green up. Hybrid cars are part of this green movement. But just how fuel efficient is a hybrid vehicle, and how green are they? The article below will explore these questions, as well as explain how a hybrid vehicle works.
How Hybrid Vehicles Work
Any vehicle that combines two sources of power is considered a hybrid. There are several types of hybrids—gasoline-electric, diesel-electric, and nuclear-electric (found in submarines). The most common type of hybrid is the gasoline-electric. In a standard gasoline engine, gasoline supplies power to the engine, which in turn supplies power to the transmission, which turns the wheels. In a straight electric vehicle, powerful batteries provide power to an electric motor, which turns the transmission and thus, the wheels. Gasoline-electric hybrids use both technologies.
Gasoline-electric hybrids have:
• a (smaller) gasoline motor
• a gasoline fuel tank
• an electric motor
• batteries
• transmission
• in some cases, it may also have a generator
Gasoline-electric hybrids use both the gasoline and electric motors to power the transmission. When and how the gasoline and electric motors specifically operate depends on the hybrid model. In general, however, the gasoline motor is primarily used at start-up, when accelerating at higher speeds, running at higher speeds, and whenever the vehicle is under strain—climbing mountain passes, for example.
So, what does the electric motor do? The electric motor provides extra power to the transmission, so it’s not relying on the gasoline motor alone. Under certain driving circumstances, the electric motor can power the vehicle alone. At speeds less than 15 mph hour, for example, the gasoline motor isn’t needed, and in most models, will shut off completely.
As in the straight electric vehicle, a series of batteries power the electric motor. These batteries can be charged while driving, capturing any excess energy the vehicle is producing. When decelerating or braking, for example, energy is put into the batteries.
How Fuel Efficient are Hybrids?
The fuel efficiency in hybrids is achieved by several means.
• an efficient electric motor
• a smaller, lighter gasoline motor
• aerodynamics
• light-weight materials
Many standard vehicles also use these means—except for the electric motor, of course—to achieve fuel efficiency, and many smaller standard vehicles get comparable gas mileage. While the 2009 Toyota Prius Hybrid is reported to get between 45-48 mpg, the Nissan Altima Hybrid only reports 33-35 mpg. In sum, the fuel efficiency of hybrids varies widely, and may or may not be better than a standard gasoline engine, or, especially, a standard diesel engine.
How Green are Hybrids?
While most hybrid vehicles do consume less gasoline than standard gasoline engines, they do still consume gasoline, which still contributes to global warming. In addition, a standard gasoline engine in good condition and getting the same miles to the gallon as a hybrid produces the same amount of emissions. Therefore, to truly make a hybrid significantly greener than a standard vehicle, additional batteries and a plug-in station are needed.
Note: Diesel engines are significantly more fuel efficient than gasoline engines, and can easily compete with the mpg of a hybrid. Though the past’s diesel engines were “dirty,” today’s diesel technology is exceptionally cleaner. A diesel running biofuel, or mixed with biofuel, is another green alternative.
How about those batteries? The good news is, they aren’t lead-acid batteries found in typical vehicles. Hybrid batteries are composed of hundreds of cells of nickel-metal hydride, which has a much lower environmental impact. Nickel-metal hydride is rechargeable and recyclable. The downside is, the components of the batteries must still be mined, and mining isn’t generally environmentally friendly.
And what about that plug-in station? If your electricity is generated from renewable sources, such as wind or solar, you’re good to go. If you plug into an outlet whose electricity is generated from a coal fired power plant, that’s not so good. If you have no idea where your power comes from, chances are it’s being generated from coal, nuclear, or natural gas.
Pros and Cons
Hybrid vehicles have advantages and disadvantages.
Pros:
• Hybrids are quiet.
• Hybrids, on average, get better fuel economy than standard gasoline engines.
• Hybrids produce less pollution than a standard gasoline engine, but only if they’re getting better gas mileage.
• Advances technology and consumer awareness.
• Qualifies for a one-time tax credit.
Cons:
• Price of vehicle. Hybrids can cost around $10,000 more than a standard vehicle.
• Price of batteries. Although most companies claim their batteries will last the life of the car, batteries are prone to dying, and batteries are expensive to replace.
• Cost of maintaining a hybrid vehicle is more expensive than the cost of maintaining a standard vehicle.
• Hybrids are only greener if their getting more miles to the gallon. They are still producing carbon emissions, however.
So, are hybrid vehicles truly greener? In many circumstances, yes. How much greener depends on the vehicle’s actual fuel economy, however.

